Negative Returns in Debt Funds – What should be your investment strategy now? (2024)

The duration funds which are running a maturity of more than 2 years and above are giving negative returns.

Debt mutual funds are considered to be relatively less volatile than equity mutual funds. While this may be true, especially over a long time, the probability of negative returns cannot be ruled out in the shorter term. There are about 16 different categories of mutual fund schemes based largely on the maturity profile of their underlying securities. And, the average return in most of the debt funds in 2021 has been negative till date. Some of the debt fund categories are in negative territory for over the 3-month period as well. “The duration products are giving negative returns, funds which are running a maturity of more than 2 years and above. The short term and above category are giving negative returns,” says informs Murthy Nagarajan, Head-Fixed Income, Tata Mutual Fund.

There is no exposure to equities in debt funds and the underlying securities include a mix of money market instruments, private sector bonds, government securities etc. Some debt funds are only into government securities called Gilt funds, while those primarily in private sector bonds are Credit risk funds. So, what could be the reason for the sudden fall in the debt funds NAVs that investors are seeing?

The impending effect of rising inflation could be the reason that most believe. As growth comes back not just in India but globally, inflation is being seen to rise. “Globally, yields have moved up due to higher commodity prices. The market is worried, this may lead to higher inflation in the coming years forcing central banks to hike interest rates,” says Nagarajan.

Negative Returns in Debt Funds – What should be your investment strategy now? (1)

TRUST Mutual Fund launches maiden equity scheme ‘Flexi Cap Fund’

Negative Returns in Debt Funds – What should be your investment strategy now? (2)

Decoding mutual fund exit load: Calculation methods and types explained

Negative Returns in Debt Funds – What should be your investment strategy now? (3)

10 things investors should check before investing in mutual funds

Negative Returns in Debt Funds – What should be your investment strategy now? (4)

SIP Calculator 10 years: 5 Small Cap Funds turn Rs 5,000/month into over Rs 25 lakh corpus!

Rising yield (or falling bond prices) happens when bond investors dump existing bond holdings in expectation of high-interest rates in forthcoming bonds. For growth, the government needs funds and often resorts to borrowing from the market to meet the shortfall. “ Higher borrowing programme of the government is the main reason for upward movement in yields,” adds Nagarajan.

Noticeably, NAVs of Gilt funds and ‘Gilt Fund with 10-year constant duration’ are two categories that have fallen the most in the short term. Nagarajan says “In the last one month, ten-year bond yields have moved up by 30 basis points, 2 years to the 5-year segment has seen yields moving up by 50 to 80 basis points, the 15-year segment yields have moved up by 40 basis points. The benchmark for the Gilt fund is 11 years and market players if they are holding any positions, could have made losses. As the yield curve has moved up across the maturities, we are seeing this steep fall in Gilt funds.”

Strategy for investors

So, what should investors do now? “We advise investors to stick to the asset allocation framework and be patient to tide over the volatility in different asset classes. Changing asset allocation can be disastrous for the investors asall asset classes have their ups and downs,” suggests Nagarajan.

However, if the spike in the yields continues in near future, it may be better for investors to shift funds within the debt fund category. “ Investor who require the money in the next 6 month to one year, can look to redeem from the high duration products and invest in low duration products.” and, for investors looking to park funds in debt funds for meeting goals which are around three years away, Nagarajan says “The low duration category and money market category could be the categories in which the first-time investors can look at investing. As we expect interest rates may move up we don’t recommend long-duration funds. Investors may only invest in funds which have a good portfolio and avoid funds taking credit calls.”

Negative Returns in Debt Funds – What should be your investment strategy now? (2024)

FAQs

Negative Returns in Debt Funds – What should be your investment strategy now? ›

So, what should investors do now? “We advise investors to stick to the asset allocation framework and be patient to tide over the volatility in different asset classes. Changing asset allocation can be disastrous for the investors as all asset classes have their ups and downs,” suggests Nagarajan.

Should you invest in debt funds now? ›

Debt mutual fund investors will benefit

But what about investors planning to invest in debt mutual funds in the upcoming financial year? Reddy says, "Existing debt mutual fund investors will benefit the most as they will get capital gain benefit, as the price of bond increases with a fall in bond yields.

Can debt funds give negative returns? ›

Investors start to expect that interest rate will fall more in future which further leads to an increase in current rates. This works best for existing bonds. This same kind of scenario was expected when Corona crisis hit the economy, but surprisingly debt funds gave negative returns.

Is it bad to have a negative Return on investment? ›

Key Takeaways

A negative rate of return is a loss of the principal invested for a specific period of time. The negative may turn into a positive in the next period, or the one after that. A negative rate of return is a paper loss unless the investment is cashed in.

Why are debt funds not performing? ›

It is difficult for debt mutual funds to earn higher returns than banks, for the same level of credit risk. Debt funds face significant disadvantages. Unlike bank deposits which are insured for Rs 5 lakhs, there is no such safety net for debt fund investors. Both banks and debt funds are exposed to credit risk.

Are debt funds safe during recession? ›

Debt funds are ideal for investors who are looking for a low-risk investment option that offers moderate returns. They are an ideal investment option for conservative investors who are looking for regular income, short-term investors, and those who want to diversify their portfolios.

Which debt fund to invest now? ›

Best Performing Debt Mutual Funds
Scheme NameExpense Ratio1Y Return
Aditya Birla Sun Life Banking & PSU Debt Fund #1 of 16 in Banking and PSU0.38%6.98% p.a.
Aditya Birla Sun Life Low Duration Fund #1 of 20 in Low Duration0.39%7.64% p.a.
Nippon India Money Market Fund #1 of 15 in Money Market0.24%7.66% p.a.
7 more rows

What are the average returns from debt funds? ›

List of Debt Mutual Funds in India
Fund NameCategory1Y Returns
HDFC Regular Savings FundDebt6.3%
Sundaram Low Duration FundDebt7.3%
Sundaram Short Duration FundDebt7.0%
UTI Short Duration FundDebt7.6%
12 more rows

Which is better to invest equity or debt? ›

Generally, debt funds are considered safer than equity funds because they primarily invest in fixed-income securities with lower volatility. However, the level of safety depends on the credit quality and maturity of the underlying securities.

Are short-term debt funds safe? ›

Short Duration Funds usually have lower default risk as compared to credit risk funds as these are mostly investment-grade securities and any investment in equities which is lower than 65% is not treated as equity but rather as a debt fund.

How many years in a 20-year period can you expect a negative return? ›

A well-managed balanced or higher-risk portfolio would expect to see positive returns in about three out of every four years. That means, over a 20-year period, it can expect five or six negative ones.

Should you invest if NPV is negative? ›

What is the Net Present Value Rule? The net present value rule is an investment concept stating that projects should only be engaged in if they demonstrate a positive net present value (NPV). Additionally, any project or investment with a negative net present value should not be undertaken.

What to do with negative stocks? ›

Conversely, if the securities depreciate in value, resulting in a loss, they will have a negative return on their investments. Investors can offset the losses in a portfolio against the gains to reduce their capital gains tax.

Which is the safest debt fund category? ›

Two fund categories, Overnight Funds and Liquid Funds fall in this category. These are the safest funds in the debt category with negligible interest or credit risk.

What are the new rules for debt funds? ›

Taxability of Debt Mutual Funds After 1st April 2023

So, debt mutual funds will be taxed at applicable slab rates. Indexation benefits will also not be available for LTCG on gold mutual funds, international equity mutual funds, and hybrid mutual funds. This will increase the tax applicable on such profits.

What is run-down strategy in debt funds? ›

In a roll-down approach, a fund maintains a portfolio of bonds that all mature at the same future date. As the maturity date draws nearer, the tenure for which the fund holds bonds reduces (rolls down). Any fresh bond purchases are also aligned with the remaining maturity of the portfolio.

What happens to debt funds when interest rates rise? ›

When interest rates rise, debt funds with longer maturities are more susceptible to interest rate risk than those with shorter maturities. This is because longer-dated bonds are more sensitive to interest rate changes than shorter-dated bonds.

Should I pause investing to pay off debt? ›

Investing and paying down debt are both good uses for any spare cash you might have. Investing makes sense if you can earn more on your investments than your debts are costing you in terms of interest. Paying off high-interest debt is likely to provide a better return on your money than almost any investment.

Should I keep investments or pay off debt? ›

In general, if you can expect a higher return on your investments than the interest rate that you pay on your debt, you should consider your investment options. Paying off debt is important, but you need to invest in your future.

Is it a good time to invest in long-term bond funds? ›

Yes, this is a good time to invest in long duration bonds. Though some expectation of rate cuts are already priced in. But if rate cuts do materialize you would certainly benefit from appreciation of bond prices as yields drop.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aron Pacocha

Last Updated:

Views: 5321

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (48 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aron Pacocha

Birthday: 1999-08-12

Address: 3808 Moen Corner, Gorczanyport, FL 67364-2074

Phone: +393457723392

Job: Retail Consultant

Hobby: Jewelry making, Cooking, Gaming, Reading, Juggling, Cabaret, Origami

Introduction: My name is Aron Pacocha, I am a happy, tasty, innocent, proud, talented, courageous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.